Hand-tossed. Thin Crust. Homemade Dough. Made with the kind of attitude only this city can serve.
The Menu
San Marzano · Premium Mozzarella
Thick Square Crust · San Marzano · Mozzarella
San Marzano · Mozzarella · Basil · EVOO
San Marzano · Stracciatella · Pecorino Romano · Basil
Cup & Char Pepperoni · Bacon · Meatball · Sausage
BBQ Sauce · Grilled or Fried Chicken · Premium Mozzarella
Buffalo Sauce · Grilled or Fried Chicken · Premium Mozzarella
Pesto · Tomato · Fresh Mozzarella · Basil · Balsamic Glaze · EVOO
Ranch Base · Grilled or Fried Chicken · Bacon · Ranch Drizzle
San Marzano · House Fried Eggplant · Ricotta
Ham · Pineapple
Ricotta · Mozzarella · Roasted Garlic · EVOO
Spicy Red Sauce · Pepperoni · Jalapeños · Banana Peppers · Mozzarella
Pepperoni · Bacon · Meatball · Sausage · Peppers · Onions · Mushrooms
Mushrooms · Black Olives · Red Onion · Bell Peppers · Banana Peppers
Pesto · Dill Pickles · Roasted Garlic · Pecorino Romano
Homemade Vodka Sauce · Fried or Grilled Chicken · Fresh Mozzarella · Fresh Basil
Philly Steak · Sautéed Onions · Hot Cherry Peppers · Cooper Sharp American · Mozzarella · Calabrian Chili Cream Sauce
The Menu
Ziti · Ricotta · Mozzarella · Pomodoro · Basil
Fettuccine · Grilled Chicken · Alfredo · Parmesan
Penne · Homemade Vodka Sauce · Fresh Basil · Parmesan
Spaghetti · House Meatballs · Pomodoro · Ricotta
Pasta Layers · Ricotta · Beef · Mozzarella
Breaded Eggplant · Ricotta · Mozzarella · Marinara · Basil
Our Story
Three generations. Zero compromises. Beginning with Reziero Vitolo opening and operating Pizzeria's In the Bronx, Yonkers, New Windsor, and Newburgh, NY... Reziero's has been tossing dough and serving slices since the early 60's in the United States.
Today, we still use the same recipes Reziero brought from Sarno, Italy all those years ago. Some things don't need improving.
Our Journey
After decades of serving the neighborhoods of New York, the Vitolo family brought their craft south. Same dough. Same sauce. Same attitude. Now hand-tossing slices on Bayshore Blvd for a new city that deserves the real thing.
Tampa may not be the Bronx, but a proper slice is a proper slice. Come taste what three generations of New York pizza-making looks like in Florida.
Real reviews from Google
W.
Local Guide · 150 reviews
Dine in | Lunch | $10–20
"Reminds you of a NY pizza joint from the outside, fortunately doesn't disappoint when you take a bite, like a lot of Florida Pizza does. Knows what you mean when you ask for well done. (Another thing FL pizza places don't do well). Hard to find a good NY slice in FL, but this is it."
via Google Reviews
E.
Local Guide · 27 reviews
Dine in
"Incredibly good pizza and lots of gourmet varieties. Very comfortable and friendly environment as well. Highly recommend! 👍💯"
via Google Reviews
S. O.
Local Guide · 43 reviews
Dine in | Lunch | $10–20
"Have been here twice since moving back to Tampa. Delicious food, quick and friendly service, and cozy setting. Got the chicken parm hero one time, and the two slice special the second time. Will be back!"
via Google Reviews
C. G.
12 reviews
Dine in | Dinner | $10–20
"While in Tampa we ate at this absolutely amazing pizza restaurant! This was so amazing until I ordered pizzas to bring home to northern Florida panhandle!"
via Google Reviews
J. H.
4 reviews
Take out | Dinner | $1–10
"I've been to this place a handful of times now and I'm obsessed. The best pizza I've found in Tampa, maybe even anywhere. Incredible sauce. I crave their pizza all the time. They do get pretty busy on weekends so give them extra time to make it."
via Google Reviews
New on the Menu
Tender Philly steak, sautéed onions, hot cherry peppers, Cooper Sharp American cheese, and melted mozzarella, finished with a drizzle of our homemade spicy Calabrian chili cream sauce.